Benjamin and Max Goldberg, the brothers behind the restaurant group Strategic Hospitality, are no strangers to breaking away from the pack. The hospitality group boasts a unique roster of establishments such as Pinewood Social, complete with bowling alley, bocce ball court and two swimming pools, and The Catbird Seat, with its chef-driven, interactive dining experience. The Downtown Sporting Club, which offers, among other activities, ax-throwing, is the newest addition to the family.

The brothers opened the venture this spring, designed by Kristen Newton of Manuel Zeitlin Architects with interior design by Reunion Goods & Services, in the same building that previously housed their honky-tonk, Paradise Park, incorporating dining options, an elaborate game room, a rooftop bar and guest rooms. Their landlord had decided to sell, so the Goldbergs found investors, paid $27 million for the three-story structure and made their vision a reality.

Closing Paradise Park was bittersweet for Benjamin and Max as it was the first venture they opened together 12 years ago. When it closed, it had just had its best year ever. Change was inevitable, though, once they bought the building. Paradise Park had only occupied the first floor. “The reality is, a three-floor Paradise Park probably would not be the same as what it was,” says Benjamin. “What’s happening on Lower Broadway right now is Dierks has a bar; Jason Aldean has a bar; Luke Bryan has a bar; Alan Jackson has a bar; John Rich has a bar. Honestly, if they want their bar to be busy, all they have to do is step foot in it and play. If Max and I ever played music in a honky-tonk, I promise you, they’d be running out of the exit, not into the entrance, so we’re at a fundamental disadvantage in that scenario.”

A Long Time Coming

The brothers had been working on plans for the Downtown Sporting Club for over five years. The timing just seemed right. The 42,000-square-foot complex offers three dining options; a game room with arcade games, shuffleboard, cornhole, foosball, and ax-throwing; 20 guest rooms; and a rooftop bar, where Strategic Hospitality’s eventspace, Aerial, used to be. Despite its size, the place has a warm, homey feel, typified by a second-floor sitting room with a dark brown leather sofa, assorted knickknacks and books on a tabletop.

Namesake

Many of the spaces are an ode to the Carter family, the original owners of the 1949 building. Guests enter into an open lobby area – the Carter Assembly — which serves as a cafe by day and a bar by night, complemented by a Crema coffee bar. The Ribbon Room features classic American fare, and the second-floor R.E.C. (Richard Edward Carter) Room serves bar food, including pizza fries and a chili-cheese dog. Chef Amy Deaderick relocated from Los Angeles to oversee all three restaurants.

Game On

In addition to arcade games, there are 21 TVs in thesecond floor R.E.C. Room, including those for patrons who reserve banquettes. “If you want to watch a game or Flip or Flop, you can,” says Tara Tocco, communications director for Strategic Hospitality. A highlight is the much-buzzed-about ax-throwing with multiple bays, which includes a coach for the one-hour sessions. For those who prefer a more relaxing activity, lawn chairs on artificial grass surround a 14-foot movie screen, where patrons can cheer on their favorite teams.

Make Room

The goal was to keep the rooms quiet and reasonably priced — starting at $179 per night. One room has two sets of full-size bunk beds and a sitting area, sort of like sleep-away camp but with better sheets. There’s a “cozy queen” at 180 square feet and a king with floor-to-ceiling windows facing Broadway. While the rooms are designed to be soundproof, there’s a “Lower Broadway Sound Mitigation System” by the bed: ear plugs and a mini bottle of Jack Daniel's.