Local Flavor: In Need of a Pick-Me-Up

Tiramisu is my madeleine, a small confection that serves a banquet of nostalgia. But it’s not so much the boozy hit of cream and coffee that evokes memories of Nashville past; it’s the recipe itself — or maybe I should say the lack thereof.

I first heard of tiramisu a little more than 25 years ago, when Nashville was a very different city. I was whiling away summer vacation with two high school friends, one of whom had just returned from Epcot with her college boyfriend. Keep in mind, Epcot was only about a decade old then, so it made for a rather dazzling date. As she narrated her romantic getaway, one detail stood out: tiramisu, an exotic dessert made with ladyfingers, mascarpone cheese, coffee and liqueur. We listened intently, enthralled as much by a dessert whose Italian name translated to “pick me up” as by the fledgling romance.

As luck would have it, her big-city boyfriend was coming to visit her in Nashville, so we decided he must be fêted with a homemade tiramisu. The problem was we had no idea how to make one. There was no internet to search, and the Joy of Cooking and The Silver Palate Cookbook in our mothers’ 20th-century kitchens were decidedly tiramisu-free. There was no Coco’s Italian Market or Kalamatas. Heck, there wasn’t even an Olive Garden or a Maggiano’s in Nashville. The Old Spaghetti Factory served spumoni. Fortunately, my mom had recently read about tiramisu, and she had an idea.

“Call Mario,” she said. If anyone in Nashville would have a tiramisu recipe, it would be him. We looked up Mario’s Ristorante in the phone book, dialed, and someone answered the phone. (Remember when restaurants answered phones?) We explained our situation. The voice on the phone hollered to the kitchen. The kitchen hollered back. The voice on the phone told us to come get Chef’s recipe. We wrapped our beach towels around ourselves, slapped flip-flops on our feet and zipped through Hillsboro Village in a lemon-yellow Cadillac at rush hour.

Mario’s Ristorante occupied a European-inspired house on the banks of Broadway at the current site of the Aertson Hotel, Nada and Henley restaurants, and the already erstwhile Caviar & Bananas. We parked on the street near the now-departed Wild Boar restaurant and entered Mario’s dining room, where servers were setting tables for dinner. If memory serves, Chef arrived shortly in houndstooth trousers and a white coat. He was smoking. While servers polished wine stems all around us, Chef listened to our tale of hometown woe, about the cosmopolitan boyfriend coming to visit our tiramisu-free backwater.

“So, you want to know how to make the tiramisu,” Chef said, with a gravelly voice and an accent that rang of Italy or France or just somewhere outside our drawling Dogpatch. “Yes, we want to make the tiramisu,” we nodded in reverent unison. He gazed toward the heavens, as if the divine recipe for tiramisu existed in the restaurant ceiling. “I tell you what you’re gonna need,” he said. We leaned closer, pencils and recipe cards ready. All we needed to ensure true love was the formula for a perfect tiramisu. Our friend’s romantic life was in Chef’s hands. Mario’s chef was our Ursula the sea witch. Chef nodded, then shrugged, then cocked his head, as if he were tasting the words of the recipe for seasoning. At last, he spoke.

“You’re going to need some espresso.” Espresso. We scribbled frantically. Got it. “You’re going to need ladyfingers.” Ladyfingers. Check. “You’re going to need about 90 egg yolks.” OK, fine, maybe he didn’t really say 90 egg yolks. Maybe he just said 64 or 48 or 30. I don’t remember, but I do remember that whatever number of eggs Chef was accustomed to cracking to prepare tiramisu for a dining room full Nashville’s elite was nothing short of absurd. You might even say it was as preposterous as the idea that once upon a time you could call a chef on a landline, zip down 21st Avenue at rush hour, park on the street and borrow a recipe from the fanciest restaurant in town. But that's exactly what we did. And, with the help of some complex fractions, that recipe worked. The boyfriend was dazzled — temporarily, at least. I haven't heard boo about him since. He’s gone — gone like Mario’s Ristorante, gone like lazy summers in a sleepy hometown. But like the creamy coffee-tinged layers of a tiramisu, the memory of that bygone Nashville is a sweet pick-me-up, indeed.