Thanksgiving is right around the corner, and whether you're hosting dinner or attending as a guest, it's imperative that pie is part of the meal. Fortunately, there are an abundance of to-go options from local bakeries and restaurants that will make the perfect addition to your gathering. If you're looking for an easy dessert that will look and taste homemade, check out one of these local options to end your holiday on a sweet note.
Baked on 8th
This year’s Baked on 8th Thanksgiving pie menu includes traditional pumpkin pie, pumpkin crumble pie, pecan pie, derby pie and salted caramel apple crumble pie. They’ll also have their famous Jewish apple cake available for preorder. See all their treats and order online at bakedon8th.com.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
Franklin’s Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop’s Thanksgiving menu includes 9-inch pies, mini 4-inch pies and thumbprint cookies. Flavors include pecan, key lime, Granny’s Apple, pumpkin, chocolate cream, Southern custard and I-40, a chess-like filling loaded with pecans, chocolate chips and toasted coconut. Order online at buttermilkskypie.com for pickup Nov. 22-24.
CaityPie’s is offering six different flavors this season, including salted caramel apple, cranberry lime, coffee chess, pumpkin streusel and CaityPies’ famous Frankenpie, a whole pie made up of one slice from all six flavors. Order online at caitypies.com for pickup at Hunters Station Nov. 24-25.
Dozen’s Thanksgiving menu features more than just pies. The beloved bakery is also offering assorted pastries and breads, cranberry sauce, green bean casserole and sourdough cubes for holiday preorders. As for pie, flavors include pumpkin, apple, buttermilk pear, butterscotch pecan and chocolate cream. Order online at dozen-nashville.com by Saturday, Nov. 20, for pickup Nov. 22-24.
Slow Hand Coffee and Bakeshop
Slow Hand Coffee and Bakeshop’s Thanksgiving menu is loaded with gorgeous offerings, from a lemon cream pie topped with a cloud of whipped cream and a candied lemon slice to the salted caramel cream pie, smothered with salted caramel drizzle. Keep an eye on their Instagram account for the full menu and ordering instructions.
If you want pie from Sweet Creations in Germantown, you’ll have to call 615-255-5519 or stop by their Jefferson Street shop, as online orders aren’t an option. But it’s worth the effort, because the beloved pie shop serves up some of the best in town. (In the Nashville Scene’s 2019 pumpkin pie taste test, Sweet Creations was praised for tasting the most homebaked.) Their fudge pie is not to be missed, either.
Yellow and Lavender
Vegans don’t have to go without dessert, thanks to Yellow & Lavender. Their Thanksgiving options include a classic pecan pie, a chocolate bourbon chess pie topped with smoked salt, a butter pie topped with shortbread cookie crumble and The OG Pie Cake, “a 6-inch pecan pie sandwiched between two 6-inch pumpkin pie sponge cakes and tons of buttercream.” Order online at yellowandlavender.com for pickup at their one-year anniversary party at Otto’s on Nov. 21.
Other Sweet Treats
If you want dinner and all the fixings, Anzie Blue is offering up a four-person family meal with your choice of meat, a variety of sides and, of course, pecan, sweet potato or Dutch apple pie. If your Thanksgiving plans involve getting cozy around an outdoor fire pit, though, consider picking up one of their s’mores boards, a sweet selection of marshmallows, graham crackers, chocolate, pretzels, peanut butter cups, strawberries and a variety of sauces to take your toasted marshmallows to the next level. Order online at anzieblue.com by 6 p.m. on Nov. 19 for pickup Nov. 24.
Who needs pie when you have Dessert Designs’ famous caramel cake? The last day to order from the bakery’s full menu — including pecan pie, pumpkin pie, yeast rolls and more — is Nov. 10. After the 10th, orders will be limited to their quick order items — caramel cake, bundt cakes, apple cake, firefly cake and a few other treats — until sold out. They’ll even add pretty fall decorations for an extra $15. Order online at dessertdesignsbyleland.com.
Fatbelly Pretzel has both sweet and savory Thanksgiving specials, including pretzel dinner rolls and whipped pimento cheese dip. If you want to end your meal with something unique, try their chocolate pretzel babka banana pudding or their vanilla bean pretzel bread pudding. Their fantastic pretzel crunch cookies are also available. Order online at fatbellypretzel.com for pickup at the East Nashville Farmers Market on Nov. 23.
East Nashville’s HiFi Cookies has everything you need for a pie-inspired dessert spread, including a chocolate chip cookie pie, Apple Bottom cookies filled with apple pie filling, pecan pie brownies and pumpkin blondies. Order online at hificookies.com for Nov. 23-24 pickup.
Little Gourmand is offering an array of fancy French delights for the holiday. Their preorder menu includes eclairs, fruit tartlets, assorted pastries and a gorgeous limited-edition dessert called “Automne,” with orange and carrot génoise, pumpkin and apricot cream, apricot mousse, vanilla shortbread cookies, and roasted hazelnuts. Want something less sweet? They also have savory macarons, including foie gras mousse and fig, Roquefort and pear, goat cheese and walnut, and smoked salmon and dill. Order online at littlegourmand.us for Nov. 24 pickup.